Best for Meat: Rastelli’s at rastellis.com
“A one-stop meat shop with beef, pork, poultry, seafood, and even plant-based meat.”
Best for Gifts: MOUTH at mouth.com
“Get gift boxes carefully curated for every recipient: grill masters, coworkers, cocktail enthusiasts—the list goes on.”
Best for Wild Game Meat: D’Artagnan at dartagnan.com
“From venison to wild boar to pheasant, D’Artagnan has the best wild game.”
Best for Seafood: Vital Choice at vitalchoice.com
“Delicious wild and organic seafood in all forms, including cans and seafood-based supplements.”
Best for Cheese: iGourmet at igourmet.com
“Hundreds of specialty cheeses from 36 countries. Enough said.”
Best for Antipasti: Di Bruno Bros at dibruno.com
“Get your antipasti spread on with Di Bruno’s house made pepper shooters and olive selection from around the world.”
Best for Jams and Salsas: Stonewall Kitchen at stonewallkitchen.com
“The founders got their start selling jellies at farmers’ markets, but the store now offers so much more.”
Best for Spices and Seasonings: Spice House at thespicehouse.com
“Spices and spice blends from all over the world, shoppable by family, region, specialty, and use.”
Best for Baked Goods: Goldbelly at goldbelly.com
“Order cakes, bagels, cookies, bread, scones, babka, and more from your favorite bakeries.”
Best for Oils: Formaggio Kitchen at formaggiokitchen.com
“Find olive oil, truffle oil, walnut oil, and more from tiny producers around the world.”